[Euan]

I think that's a very good idea, guys. It creates more official reviews (possibly) while also hopefully maintaining your high standards.

I also think if you are going to do a fail/pass system, those who fail, without being too harsh, mention what they could do to improve it to make it a pass, which in turn would maybe help the writer, too.

Right OK now that's been cleared up, I apologise to Shadowmarth, didn't mean to get in a big argument but I felt strongly about my case and I'm not trying to change the site beyond my power. I'm putting forward suggestions, just as other people are with suggestions for new boards etc. Although I THINK it will work better, maybe Chuddy and Allen don't, that's up to them. I think I deserve an apology too since in the end, I didn't really do anything wrong.