[ShadowMarth]

Hold it right there. GW is NOT inferior to WoW, and it certainly isn't "lower quality." It's a great, fun game with 100s of hours of single player and much more in PvP, and that's without the expansions. Blizzard is an amazing developer, and they make amazing games, but they just tend to like pissing people off some times. What with the strange patch updates, messed up changes in BC, the subscription fee to begin with, and the fact that they have abandoned all other of their amazing games for this one. I want SC2 damn it!

However blizzard still wins in the end, since I finally found a game to rip my impoverished friends away from WoW. Starcraft. Hrm, guess I havn't actually give a straight answer to this thread yet... So, I say X-Com, Starcraft, and Guild Wars, in that order. Civ IV is up there though, as are countless others...